Skip to contentVIOLATIONS OF PROBATION (VOPs)
Introduction
Florida Statutes Chapter 948defines probation as a form of community supervision that imposes certain terms and conditions on an offender instead of imprisonment.
The Sheriff’s Office supervises misdemeanor probation.The Florida Department of Corrections supervises felony probation. Violating conditions of probation often has serious implications and may result in the revocation, and subsequent incarceration, of an offender.
What Constitutes a Violation of Probation (VOP)?
Under Florida law, a violation of probation occurs when a defendant willfully and substantially fails to comply with the terms and conditions of his or her probationary sentence.
Whether a violation was both willful and substantial in nature depends on the facts of each individual case and must be proven by the State by the “greater weight of the evidence.”
Here are a few examples of non-willfulviolations:
- Thorpe v. State, 642 So. 2d 629 (Fla. 1st DCA 1994) (stating that “[w]here a probationer has made reasonable efforts to comply with the terms of probation, his or her failure to do so has been held not to be willful”)
- Green v. State, 620 So. 2d 1126 (Fla. 1st DCA 1993) (no willful violation of probation where an unemployed probationer was unable to make restitution)
- White v. State, 619 So. 2d 429, 431 (Fla. 1st DCA), review denied, 626 So.2d 208 (Fla.1993) (no willful violation of probation where a probationer, who failed to perform community service, had reported to the community service work site “many times” but was told that work was not available)
- Rainer v. State, 657 So. 2d 1230, 1230 (Fla. 4th DCA 1995) (failure to complete drug rehabilitation program not shown to be willful where uncontradicted testimony indicated that a mental illness interfered with the defendant’s ability to follow instructions)
- Shaw v. State, 391 So. 2d 754 (Fla. 5th DCA 1980) (no willful violation of condition requiring personal delivery of a report when timely completed report was not delivered because of probationer’s lack of transportation and subsequent incarceration for an unrelated offense)
Violations
Probation can be violated in one of two ways: a technical violation or a substantive violation.
Technical Violations
In analyzing a potential VOP always examine the willfulness of the probationer’s conduct.
Probation violations in Florida fall into one of two categories: technical or willful.
A technical violation occurs when a probationer violates either a specific or general condition of his or her probation. These typically include things like:
- Failure to pay court costs and fines:
- When a probationer fails to pay court costs and/or fines, courtsmust consider the willfulness and the ability of the probationer to pay. The burden falls on the probationer by clear and convincing evidence to prove that he or she is unable to pay.If the court does not find that the probationer has the ability, it cannot violate the probationer. SeeSmith v. State, 892 So.2d 513 (Fla. 1st DCA 2004);Martin v. State, 937 So.2d 714 (Fla. 1st DCA 2006);
- Failure to complete court-ordered programs such as drug rehabilitation or mental-health counseling:
- If the State can establish that the probationer was responsible for failing to complete his or her court-ordered substance abuse program, a probation violation has occurred, and the court may revoke or modify probation.See Grannemann v. State, 85 So.3d 1186 (Fla. 5th DCA 2012)
- However, if the state fails to prescribe a specific time period for entrance into, or completion of, the court-ordered program, a probationer’s failure to enter and complete such a program cannot be the basis for revocation. See Quintero v. State, 902 So.2d 236 (Fla. 2nd DCA 2005)
- When a probationer fails a drug test, the State must prove that the probationer had an illegal drug in the probationer’s body by substantial competent evidence, a burden most prosecutors underestimate. A positive drug test, for instance, must be authenticatedby someone with sufficient experience and training in establishing the identity and presence of the identified contrabandin order for the court to admit it at a VOP hearing. This fact means that in most circumstance the testimony of a probation officer establishing a positive drug result will not suffice, unless the State of Florida has certified the probation officer to administer a drug tests.See Queior v. State, 157 So.3d 370 (Fla. 2d DCA 2015)
- Missing or arriving late to probation-related appointments
- Again, willfully missing or disregarding an appointment with a probation officer is likely to result in a probationer’s arrest.However, if it is a single, or isolated, instance and the probationer offers a valid explanation to the court, the court is unlikely to view the lapse as willful and substantial noncompliance. See Rodriguez v. State, 768 So.2d 1234 (Fla. 5th DCA 2000)
In each of these scenarios the alleged noncompliance must, again, be willful and substantial for a court to violate one’s probation. Although courts make this determination on a case-by-case basis, any evidence that shows that the noncompliance was due to outside, uncontrollable factors weighs in favor of the probationer.
Substantive Violations
A substantive violation occurs when a probationer commits a new crime while on probation.
When the state seeks to revoke probation based on the commission of a new offense, it must provide non-hearsay evidence that links the defendant to the commission of the new offense.An arrest alone cannot be the basis of a VOP
Penalties for Violating
If a court revokes probation, it may impose any sentence that it originally could have imposed on the defendant at sentencing.
If a supervising probation officer deems the probationer to have violated probation, he or she will submit to the court either an “Affidavit of Violation” in misdemeanor cases or a “Department of Corrections Violation Report” in felony cases. Both serve as a sworn statement outlining why the officer reasonably believes the probationer to havecommittedthe alleged violation.
The court the reviews the allegations and determines whether or not reasonable grounds exist to issue a capias or warrant for the probationer’s arrest. It the court issues either a capias or an arrest warrant, and law enforcement arrestthe probationer, the court will hold a hearing to review his or her case. While awaiting this hearing, it is likely that the probationer will be placed on a “no bond” status which requires the probationer to remain in jail until someone – i.e. a criminal defense lawyer – requestsa bond on his or her behalf.
It oftenmakes sense to make an in-court surrender on a VOP warrant. Doing so can speed up your release should the court issue a bond and/or other terms of release while you await the final VOP hearing. Otherwise, it could be anywhere from two days to weeks until you are brought before the judge. A seasoned criminal defense lawyer can help you with this step.
Process and Burdens
A VOP hearing differs substantially from a regular criminal trial. First, the evidentiary standard for the State in a VOP hearing falls substantially lower than the “beyond a reasonable doubt” standard applied in criminal trials. The State must prove by the “greater weight of the evidence” that a probationer committed a willful and substantial violation of probation. This means that it is easier for the State to prove a probationer violated.
In a Final VOP hearing, a defendant may be compelled to testify about probation matters even if such testimony could incriminate the defendant.
Similarly, hearsay is generally admissible at VOP hearing, but it cannot be the sole basis undergirding a revocation.
Your rights in a VOP hearing are substantially limited as compared to those afforded to you during a typical criminal proceeding.
To ensure that your rights are protected during a VOP proceeding, it is imperative that you contact an experienced VOP attorney.
What Are the Penalties for Violating Probation?
If a judge finds that you committed the violation, the judge has three options. According to section 948.06, Florida Statutes (2018), a judge may:
- Reinstate your Probation;
- Modify your Probation Sentence; or
- Revoke your Probation and Impose jail/prison time.
If your probation is revoked, the judge has the legal authority to impose the maximum sentence for the charge upon which you were originally placed on probation, even if the new sentence is longer than the term included in the original plea bargain, so long as the longer sentence does not exceed the statutory maximum.
Tolling of Probation
Florida Statute § 948.06(1) provides that: “Upon the filing of an affidavit alleging a violation of probation or community control and following issuance of a warrant under s. 901.02, the probationary period is tolled until the court enters a ruling on the violation.
What this means is that when a probation officer files either an “Affidavit of Violation” or a “Department of Corrections Violation Report”, the period of probation is put on pause until the court issues its ruling on the violation. Once the court rules, the probation, if reinstated or modified, resumes.
If you or someone you know needs help with a probation violation, contact Michael White for a free consultation.
crime, defender, law, jury, criminal defense lawyer, criminal procedure, lawyer, evidence, court, plea, sentence, punishment, witness, prosecutor, criminal law, criminal defenses, criminal justice, trial, advocate, internet, misdemeanor, poverty, plea bargain, justice, appeal, judge, police, criminal charge, information, insanity defense, probation, ethics, consent, trial advocacy, felony, jurisdiction, prison, public defender, conviction, advocacy, search and seizure, expert, acquittal, discovery, legal aid, arrest, verdict, ineffective assistance of counsel, confidentiality, guilt, expert witness, knowledge, courtroom, right to counsel, district attorney, research, first responder, fee, actual innocence, defense lawyers, legal studies, attorneys, attorney, defense attorneys, defense counsel, criminal defense lawyers, criminal attorneys, national, criminal defense, lawyers, criminal defense attorney, criminal lawyers, private defense attorneys, defense attorney, criminal defense attorneys, criminal lawyer, preliminary hearing, burden of proof, conflict of interest, probable cause, negotiation, appellate court, motion, american bar association, advertising, statute, money, employment, substance abuse, law enforcement, jury trial, education, reasonable doubt, fraud, statute of limitations, detention, clinic, negligence, judgment, understanding, jury selection, legal advice, rights, opening statement, data, due process, doubt, reputation, bias, skill, drug, duty, murder, health, community, immigration, officer of the court, theft, lawyer referral service, of counsel, common law, science, privilege, contract, admissible evidence, pro bono, trier of fact, evaluation, juris doctor, presumption of innocence, pardon, grand jury, tribunal, imprisonment, embezzlement, good faith, assault, policy, traffic ticket, curriculum, attention, racism, experience, credibility, south florida, everglades, airline, broward county, silver airways, the bahamas, greater fort lauderdale, history, forlader florida, fort lauder florida, sawgrass mills, yacht, caribbean, venice, tourism, ocean, germany, miami, university of south florida, college, south university tampa, south university florida, southwest florida university, university of south tampa, southern university florida, south university orlando, usf florida, southeast university florida, southern florida, university of florida tampa
What are the most common criminal defense cases handled?
The most common criminal defense cases handled include drug offenses, assault, theft, DUI charges, and domestic violence. Michael White, P.A. specializes in providing strong representation for these situations, ensuring the protection of clients' rights.
Can a criminal defense lawyer negotiate a plea deal?
A criminal defense lawyer can negotiate a plea deal on behalf of their client. This process typically involves discussing potential agreements with prosecutors to reduce charges or secure a more favorable sentence.
How do I choose a criminal defense attorney near me?
Choosing a criminal defense attorney near you involves evaluating their experience, specifically in criminal law, checking client reviews, and ensuring they are familiar with local courts. Schedule a consultation to assess their approach and compatibility with your needs.
What are the key elements of a successful criminal defense strategy?
The key elements of a successful criminal defense strategy include a thorough understanding of the case details, personalized legal tactics, effective communication with the client, and a strong focus on protecting the client's rights throughout the legal process.
What are the consequences of pleading guilty to a criminal charge?
The consequences of pleading guilty to a criminal charge include potential jail time, fines, a permanent criminal record, and loss of certain rights. It can also impact employment opportunities and personal relationships, so it’s vital to seek legal advice before making a decision.
What are the benefits of hiring a former prosecutor as a defense lawyer?
The benefits of hiring a former prosecutor as a defense lawyer include their in-depth understanding of the legal system, insight into prosecutorial strategies, and experience in negotiating favorable outcomes. This expertise can significantly enhance your defense and protect your rights.
What is the role of a criminal defense investigator in a case?
The role of a criminal defense investigator in a case is to gather evidence, interview witnesses, and build a comprehensive understanding of the circumstances surrounding the case, thereby supporting the defense attorney in presenting a strong case for the client.
What should I expect during a criminal trial?
During a criminal trial, you can expect the process to include jury selection, opening statements, presentation of evidence, witness testimonies, closing arguments, and finally, the jury's deliberation and verdict. It’s essential to be prepared for emotional and procedural challenges throughout.
How does trial strategy impact defense outcomes?
The impact of trial strategy on defense outcomes is significant. A well-crafted strategy can effectively highlight weaknesses in the prosecution's case, leverage strong defenses, and enhance the overall credibility of the defense, ultimately increasing the chances of a favorable verdict.
What evidence is crucial in criminal defense?
Crucial evidence in criminal defense includes eyewitness testimonies, alibi information, physical evidence, and expert witness reports. These elements can significantly impact the case by establishing reasonable doubt or supporting the defendant's claims.
How can I prepare for a defense consultation?
Preparing for a defense consultation involves gathering relevant documents, noting important details about your case, and preparing a list of questions for your attorney. This ensures a focused discussion and helps your attorney provide the best legal advice.
What are the signs of a good defense attorney?
The signs of a good defense attorney include strong communication skills, a solid reputation, proven trial experience, personalized legal strategies, and a commitment to protecting clients' rights. These qualities ensure effective representation in criminal cases.
When is self-defense applicable in criminal cases?
Self-defense is applicable in criminal cases when an individual reasonably believes they are facing imminent harm and uses proportional force to protect themselves from that threat.
What penalties can result from a felony conviction?
The penalties resulting from a felony conviction can include lengthy prison sentences, substantial fines, and a permanent criminal record, which may affect employment and housing opportunities, as well as the loss of certain civil rights.
How can plea bargaining benefit my case?
The benefits of plea bargaining for your case include potentially reduced charges, lighter sentences, and the opportunity to avoid the uncertainty of a trial. This strategic approach can lead to a more favorable resolution while saving time and resources.
What role do witnesses play in criminal defense?
Witnesses play a crucial role in criminal defense by providing testimonies that can support the defendant’s case, challenge the prosecution's evidence, or establish reasonable doubt. Their accounts can significantly influence the outcome of a trial.
What defenses are available for drug charges?
Defenses available for drug charges include demonstrating lack of possession, questioning the legality of the search, proving entrapment, and asserting medical necessity. Each defense can vary based on the specifics of the case and circumstances involved.
How does the appeal process work in criminal cases?
The appeal process in criminal cases involves reviewing a lower court's decision for legal errors. It typically begins with the filing of a notice of appeal, followed by the submission of briefs, and may conclude with oral arguments before an appellate court before a final decision is made.
What mistakes should I avoid in my defense?
The mistakes to avoid in your defense are crucial missteps such as speaking to law enforcement without legal counsel, failing to disclose important details to your attorney, and neglecting to follow legal advice. These errors can severely impact your case outcome.
What questions to ask potential defense attorneys?
When considering potential defense attorneys, important questions to ask include their experience with similar cases, their approach to legal strategy, how they communicate with clients, and their fee structure.
How does character evidence affect criminal cases?
Character evidence affects criminal cases by influencing the perception of a defendant’s credibility and moral character. It can be used to support claims of good character or to challenge the reliability of a witness, impacting the outcome of the case.
What options exist if I cant afford a lawyer?
Options for those who can't afford a lawyer include seeking legal aid services, applying for public defender representation, or utilizing pro bono services from nonprofit organizations and law firms.
How important is jury selection in my trial?
Jury selection is crucial in your trial as it can significantly influence the outcome. A well-selected jury can enhance the chances of a favorable verdict, highlighting the importance of this process in your legal defense strategy.
What documents should I collect for my defense?
To prepare for your defense, collect documents such as arrest records, police reports, witness statements, photographs, and any correspondence related to your case. These materials will provide crucial support for your legal representation.
In what scenarios can I seek expungement?
Expungement can be sought in scenarios such as completing a sentence for a misdemeanor or certain felonies, cases dismissed or not prosecuted, and when the individual has no pending criminal charges. Eligibility varies by jurisdiction, so consultation with an attorney is advised.
What should I know about government plea deals?
Government plea deals are agreements where a defendant pleads guilty to lesser charges in exchange for reduced penalties or to avoid trial. Understanding the implications and potential consequences is crucial for making informed decisions.
How can I challenge police evidence in court?
Challenging police evidence in court involves questioning its legality, chain of custody, or reliability. A skilled attorney can identify inconsistencies or procedural violations that may render the evidence inadmissible, ultimately protecting your rights during the trial.
What is the impact of prior convictions on sentencing?
The impact of prior convictions on sentencing is significant. Judges often consider past offenses, which can lead to harsher penalties, longer sentences, or mandatory minimums, reflecting a defendant's criminal history and perceived risk of reoffending.
How do mental health issues affect defense strategies?
Mental health issues can significantly influence defense strategies by providing grounds for diminished responsibility or competency challenges. These factors may lead to alternative sentencing options or treatment instead of punishment, ultimately shaping the legal approach taken in a case.
What is the difference between charges and allegations?
The difference between charges and allegations lies in their legal implications. Charges are formal accusations filed by law enforcement or prosecutors, while allegations are claims or assertions about wrongdoing that may not yet have led to formal charges.
michael white pa, criminal defense attorney fort lauderdale, michael white attorney, michael white lawyer
